The 2026-27 NHL season promises to be an exciting one for the Pittsburgh Penguins, with a host of potential surprise players ready to make their mark. While some names are already household names, others might fly under the radar until they become key contributors. Here's a breakdown of some players who could be the next big revelation for the Penguins.
Declan Carlile
Carlile is a young defenseman who has the potential to become a top-four matchup defender. With only 46 career games under his belt, he's yet to prove himself in the NHL. However, his underlying metrics suggest he has the skills to make a significant impact. The Penguins have a history of discovering hidden gems, and Carlile could be the next Wotherspoon or Shea, rising to prominence as a result of their success in developing young talent. If he can slot into a top-four role and handle it well, he'll be a surprise package for the team and a player to watch.
Hendrix Lapierre
Lapierre is a tertiary player who has been overlooked in recent acquisitions. However, he has the potential to be a surprise package. With the ability to play center, a position that isn't exactly settled on the team, Lapierre could find himself playing a significant role. While expectations are low, he has the potential to be a 'buy low' player who exceeds expectations. If he can play 60+ games and make a few key plays, he'll be a welcome surprise for the Penguins.
Nick Robertson
The Penguins might not have gotten the NHL star Robertson brother, but Nick Robertson has been a productive player in Toronto. With 31 goals in the last two seasons, he's shown he can score. However, with the team overstocked with scoring-line wingers, his role is uncertain. Robertson could be a surprise package if he gets a chance to shine. With a reasonable chance of scoring 20 goals and getting over 40 points, he could become a key player on the squad and a surprise for the fan base.
Bill Zonnon
Zonnon is a 20-year-old forward who will be in his first pro season next year. While it might be premature to expect a major impact, the Penguins have a history of calling up players from the AHL and giving them a chance. Zonnon took to the AHL like a fish to water, scoring a goal in each of his first three playoff games. With great wheels and a knack for going to the net, he could be a surprise package if he gets a chance to prove himself in the NHL. If he makes a good impression and keeps making things happen, he could be a dark horse candidate for a spot on the team.
Mikhail Ilyin
Ilyin is a 21-year-old forward who flashed in the AHL playoffs, scoring nine points in 15 games. With a history of being a good point-producer at a young age in the KHL, he has the potential to be a surprise package. While it might be a stretch to expect a major impact in 2026-27, he has the skills to succeed at every level. If the conditions are right, he could step up and make a name for himself, becoming a key player for the Penguins.
